Narrated by Kimberly Schraf
This file is 14.4 MB;
running time is 30 minutes
alternate download link
This audio program is copyrighted by Redwood Audiobooks.
Permission is granted to download for personal use only;
not for distribution or commercial use.
A breeze from the May world without blew through the class-room, and
as it lifted his papers he had a curious sense of freshness and
mustiness meeting. He looked at the group of students before him,
half smiling at the way the breath of spring was teasing the hair of
the girls sitting by the window. Anna Lawrence was trying to pin
hers back again, but May would have none of such decorum, and only
waited long enough for her to finish her work before joyously
undoing it. She caught the laughing, admiring eyes of a boy sitting
across from her and sought to conceal her pleasure in her
unmanageable wealth of hair by a wry little face, and then the eyes
of both strayed out to the trees that had scented that breeze for
them, looking with frank longing at the campus which stretched
before them in all its May glory that sunny afternoon. He remembered
having met this boy and girl strolling in the twilight the evening
before, and as a buoyant breeze that instant swept his own face he
had a sudden, irrelevant consciousness of being seventy-three years
Other eyes were straying to the trees and birds and lilacs of that
world from which the class-room was for the hour shutting them out.
He was used to it—that straying of young eyes in the spring. For
more than forty years he had sat at that desk and talked to young
men and women about philosophy, and in those forty years there had
always been straying eyes in May. The children of some of those boys
and girls had in time come to him, and now there were other children
who, before many years went by, might be sitting upon those benches,
listening to lectures upon what men had thought about life, while
their eyes strayed out where life called. So it went on—May,
perhaps, the philosopher triumphant.
As, with a considerable effort—for the languor of spring, or some
other languor, was upon him too—he brought himself back to the
papers they had handed in, he found himself thinking of those first
boys and girls, now men and women, and parents of other boys and
girls. He hoped that philosophy had, after all, done something more
than shut them out from May. He had always tried, not so much to
instruct them in what men had thought, as to teach them to think,
and perhaps now, when May had become a time for them to watch the
straying of other eyes, they were the less desolate because of the
habits he had helped them to form. He wanted to think that he had
done something more than hold them prisoners.
There was a sadness to-day in his sympathy. He was tired. It was
hard to go back to what he had been saying about the different
things the world's philosophers had believed about the immortality
of the soul. So, as often when his feeling for his thought dragged,
he turned to Gretta Loring. She seldom failed to bring a revival of
interest—a freshening. She was his favourite student. He did not
believe that in all the years there had been any student who had not
only pleased, but helped him as she did.
He had taught her father and mother. And now there was Gretta,
clear-eyed and steady of gaze, asking more of life than either of
them had asked; asking, not only May, but what May meant. For Gretta
there need be no duality. She was one of those rare ones for whom
the meaning of life opened new springs to the joy of life, for whom
life intensified with the understanding of it. He never said a thing
that gratified him as reaching toward the things not easy to say but
that he would find Gretta's face illumined—and always that eager
little leaning ahead for more.
She had that look of waiting now, but to-day it seemed less an
expectant than a troubled look. She wanted him to go on with what he
had been saying about the immortality of the soul. But it was not so
much a demand upon him—he had come to rely upon those demands, as
it was—he had an odd, altogether absurd sense of its being a fear
for him. She looked uncomfortable, fretted; and suddenly he was
startled to see her searching eyes blurred by something that must be
She turned away, and for just a minute it seemed to leave him alone
and helpless. He rubbed his forehead with his hand. It felt hot. It
got that way sometimes lately when he was tired. And the close of
that hour often found him tired.
He believed he knew what she wanted. She would have him declare his
own belief. In the youthful flush of her modernism she was impatient
with that fumbling around with what other men had thought. Despising
the muddled thinking of some of her classmates, she would have him
put it right to them with "As for yourself—"
He tried to formulate what he would care to say. But, perhaps just
because he was too tired to say it right, the life the robin in the
nearest tree was that moment celebrating in song seemed more
important than anything he had to say about his own feeling toward
the things men had thought about the human soul.
It was ten minutes before closing time, but suddenly he turned to
his class with: "Go out-of-doors and think about it. This is no day
to sit within and talk of philosophy. What men have thought about
life in the past is less important than what you feel about it
to-day." He paused, then added, he could not have said why, "And
don't let the shadow of either belief or unbelief fall across the
days that are here for you now." Again he stopped, then surprised
himself by ending, "Philosophy should quicken life, not deaden it."
They were not slow in going, their astonishment in his wanting them
to go quickly engulfed in their pleasure in doing so. It was only
Gretta who lingered a moment, seeming too held by his manner in
sending her out into the sunshine to care about going there. He
thought she was going to come to the desk and speak to him. He was
sure she wanted to. But at the last she went hastily, and he
thought, just before she turned her face away, that it was a tear he
saw on her lashes.
Strange! Was she unhappy, she through whom life surged so richly?
And yet was it not true, that where it gave much it exacted much?
Feeling much, and understanding what she felt, and feeling for what
she understood—must she also suffer much? Must one always pay?
He sighed, and began gathering together his papers. Thoughts about
life tired him to-day.
On the steps he paused, unreasonably enough a little saddened as he
watched some of them beginning a tennis game. Certainly they were
losing no time—eager to let go thoughts about life for its
pleasures, very few of them awake to that rich life he had tried to
make them ready for. He drooped still more wearily at the thought
that perhaps the most real gift he had for them was that unexpected
Remembering a book he must have from the library, he turned back. He
went to the alcove where the works on philosophy were to be found,
and was reaching up for the volume he wanted, when a sentence from a
lowly murmured conversation in the next aisle came to him across the
stack of books.
"That's all very well; we know, of course, that he doesn't believe,
but what will he do when it comes to himself?"
It arrested him, coming as it did from one of the girls who had just
left his class-room. He stood there motionless, his hand still
reaching up for the book.
"Do? Why, face it, of course. Face it as squarely as he's faced
every other fact of life."
That was Gretta, and though, mindful of the library mandate for
silence, her tone was low, it was vibrant with a fine scorn.
"Well," said the first speaker, "I guess he'll have to face it
before very long."
That was not answered; there was a movement on the other side of the
barricade of books—it might have been that Gretta had turned away.
His hand dropped down from the high shelf. He was leaning against
"Haven't you noticed, Gretta, how he's losing his grip?"
At that his head went up sharply; he stood altogether tense as he
waited for Gretta to set the other girl right—Gretta, so
sure-seeing, so much wiser and truer than the rest of them. Gretta
But she did not laugh. And what his strained ear caught at last
was—not her scornful denial, but a little gasp of breath suggesting
"Noticed it? Why it breaks my heart!"
He stared at the books through which her low, passionate voice had
carried. Then he sank to the chair that fortunately was beside him.
Power for standing had gone from him.
"Father says—father's on the board, you know" (it was the first
girl who spoke)—"that they don't know what to do about it. It's not
justice to the school to let him begin another year. These things
are arranged with less embarrassment in the big schools, where a man
begins emeritus at a certain time. Though of course they'll pension
him—he's done a lot for the school."
He thanked Gretta for her little laugh of disdain. The memory of it
was more comforting—more satisfying—than any attempt to put it
into words could have been.
He heard them move away, their skirts brushing the book-stacks in
passing. A little later he saw them out in the sunshine on the
campus. Gretta joined one of the boys for a game of tennis.
Motionless, he sat looking out at her. She looked so very young as
For an hour he remained at the table in the alcove where he had
overheard what his students had to say of him. And when the hour had
gone by he took up the pen which was there upon the study table and
wrote his resignation to the secretary of the board of trustees. It
was very brief—simply that he felt the time had come when a younger
man could do more for the school than he, and that he should like
his resignation to take effect at the close of the present school
year. He had an envelope, and sealed and stamped the letter—ready
to drop in the box in front of the building as he left. He had
always served the school as best he could; he lost no time now, once
convinced, in rendering to it the last service he could offer
it—that of making way for the younger man.
Looking things squarely in the face, and it was the habit of a
lifetime to look things squarely in the face, he had not been long
in seeing that they were right. Things tired him now as they had not
once tired him. He had less zest at the beginning of the hour, more
relief at the close of it. He seemed stupid in not having seen it
for himself, but possibly many people were a little stupid in seeing
that their own time was over. Of course he had thought, in a vague
way, that his working time couldn't be much longer, but it seemed
part of the way human beings managed with themselves that things in
even the very near future kept the remoteness of future things.
Now he understood Gretta's troubled look and her tears. He knew how
those fine nerves of hers must have suffered, how her own mind had
wanted to leap to the aid of his, how her own strength must have
tormented her in not being able to reach his flagging powers. It
seemed part of the whole hardness of life that she who would care
the most would be the one to see it most understandingly.
What he was trying to do was to see it all very simply, in
matter-of-fact fashion, that there might be no bitterness and the
least of tragedy. It was nothing unique in human history he was
facing. One did one's work; then, when through, one stopped. He
tried to feel that it was as simple as it sounded, but he wondered
if back of many of those brief letters of resignation that came at
quitting-time there was the hurt, the desolation, that there was no
use denying to himself was back of his.
He hoped that most men had more to turn to. Most men of
seventy-three had grandchildren. That would help, surrounding one
with a feeling of the naturalness of it all. But that school had
been his only child. And he had loved it with the tenderness one
gives a child. That in him which would have gone to the child had
gone to the school.
The woman whom he loved had not loved him; he had never married. His
life had been called lonely; but lonely though it undeniably had
been, the life he won from books and work and thinking had kept the
chill from his heart. He had the gift of drawing life from all
contact with life. Working with youth, he kept that feeling for
youth that does for the life within what sunshine and fresh air do
for the room in which one dwells.
It was now that the loneliness that blights seemed waiting for
him.... Life used one—and that in the ugly, not the noble sense
of being used. Stripped of the fine fancies men wove around it, what
was it beyond just a matter of being sucked dry and then thrown
aside? Why not admit that, and then face it? And the abundance with
which one might have given—the joy in the giving—had no bearing
upon the fact that it came at last to that question of getting one
out of the way. It was no one's unkindness; it was just that life
was like that. Indeed, the bitterness festered around the thought
that it _was_ life itself—the way of life—not the brutality
of any particular people. "They'll pension him—he's done a lot for
the school." Even the grateful memory of Gretta's tremulous,
scoffing little laugh for the way it fell short could not follow to
the deep place that had been hurt.
Getting himself in hand again, and trying to face this as simply and
honestly as he had sought to face the other, he knew that it was
true he had done a great deal for the school. He did not believe it
too much to say he had done more for it than any other man.
Certainly more than any other man he had given it what place it had
with men who thought. He had come to it in his early manhood, and at
a time when the school was in its infancy—just a crude, struggling
little Western college. Gretta Loring's grandfather had been one of
its founders—founding it in revolt against the cramping
sectarianism of another college. He had gloried in the spirit which
gave it birth, and it was he who, through the encroachings of
problems of administration and the ensnarements and entanglements of
practicality, had fought to keep unattached and unfettered that
spirit of freedom in the service of truth.
His own voice had been heard and recognised, and a number of times
during the years calls had come from more important institutions,
but he had not cared to go. For year by year there deepened that
personal love for the little college to which he had given the
youthful ardour of his own intellectual passion. All his life's
habits were one with it. His days seemed beaten into the path that
cut across the campus. The vines that season after season went a
little higher on the wall out there indicated his strivings by their
own, and the generation that had worn down even the stones of those
front steps had furrowed his forehead and stooped his shoulders. He
had grown old along with it! His days were twined around it. It was
the place of his efforts and satisfactions (joys perhaps he should
not call them), of his falterings and his hopes. He loved it because
he had given himself to it; loved it because he had helped to bring
it up. On the shelves all around him were books which it had been
his pleasure—because during some of those hard years they were to
be had in no other way—to order himself and pay for from his own
almost ludicrously meagre salary. He remembered the excitement there
always was in getting them fresh from the publisher and bringing
them over there in his arms; the satisfaction in coming in next day
and finding them on the shelves. Such had been his dissipations, his
indulgences of self. Many things came back to him as he sat there
going back over busy years, the works on philosophy looking down
upon him, the shadows of that spring afternoon gathering around him.
He looked like a very old man indeed as he at last reached out for
the letter he had written to the trustees, relieving them of their
Twilight had come on. On the front steps he paused and looked around
the campus. It was growing dark in that lingering way it has in the
spring—daylight creeping away under protest, night coming gently,
as if it knew that the world having been so pleasant, day would be
loath to go. The boys and girls were going back and forth upon the
campus and the streets. They could not bear to go within. For more
than forty years it had been like that. It would be like that for
many times forty years—indeed, until the end of the world, for it
would be the end of the world when it was not like that. He was glad
that they were out in the twilight, not indoors trying to gain from
books something of the meaning of life. That course had its
satisfactions along the way, but it was surely no port of peace to
which it bore one at the last.
He shrunk from going home. There were so many readjustments he must
make, once home. So, lingering, he saw that off among the trees a
girl was sitting alone. She threw back her head in a certain way
just then, and he knew by the gesture that it was Gretta Loring. He
wondered what she was thinking about. What did one who thought think
about—over there on the other side of life? Youth and age looked at
life from opposite sides. Then they could not see it alike, for what
one saw in life seemed to depend so entirely upon how the light was
falling from where one stood.
He could not have said just what it was made him cross the campus
toward her. Part of it was the desire for human sympathy—one thing,
at least, which age did not deaden. But that was not the whole of
it, nor the deepest thing in it. It was an urge of the spirit to
find and keep for itself a place where the light was falling
backward upon life.
She was quiet in her greeting, and gentle. Her cheeks were still
flushed, her hair tumbled from her game, but her eyes were
thoughtful and, he thought, sad. He felt that the sadness was
because of him; of him and the things of which he made her think. He
knew of her affection for him, the warmth there was in her
admiration of the things for which he had fought. He had discovered
that it hurt her now that others should be seeing and not he, pained
her to watch so sorry a thing as his falling below himself, wounded
both pride and heart that men whom she would doubtless say had never
appreciated him were whispering among themselves about how to get
rid of him. Why, the poor child might even be tormenting herself
with the idea she ought to tell him!
That was why he told her. He pointed to the address on the envelope,
saying: "That carries my resignation, Gretta."
Her start and the tears which rushed to her eyes told him he was
right about her feeling. She did not seem able to say anything. Her
chin was trembling.
"I see that the time has come," he said, "when a younger man can do
more for the school than I can hope to do for it."
Still she said nothing at all, but her eyes were deepening and she
had that very steadfast, almost inspired look that had so many times
quickened him in the class-room.
She was not going to deny it! She was not going to pretend!
After the first feeling of not having got something needed he rose
to her high ground—ground she had taken it for granted he would
"And will you believe it, Gretta," he said, rising to that ground
and there asking, not for the sympathy that bends down, but for a
hand in passing, "there comes a hard hour when first one feels the
time has come to step aside and be replaced by that younger man?"
She nodded. "It must be," she said, simply; "it must be very much
harder than any of us can know till we come to it."
She brought him a sense of his advantage in experience—his riches.
To be sure, there was that.
And he was oddly comforted by the honesty in her which could not
stoop to dishonest comforting. In what superficially might seem her
failure there was a very real victory for them both. And there was
nothing of coldness in her reserve! There was the fulness of
understanding, and of valuing the moments too highly for anything
there was to be said about it. There was a great spiritual dignity,
a nobility, in the way she was looking at him. It called upon the
whole of his own spiritual dignity. It was her old demand upon him,
but this time the tears through which her eyes shone were tears of
pride in fulfilment, not of sorrowing for failure.
Suddenly he felt that his life had not been spent in vain, that the
lives of all those men of his day who had fought the good fight for
intellectual honesty—spiritual dignity—had not been spent in vain
if they were leaving upon the earth even a few who were like the
girl beside them.
It turned him from himself to her. She was what counted—for she was
what remained. And he remained in just the measure that he remained
through her; counted in so far as he counted for her. It was as if
he had been facing in the wrong direction and now a kindly hand had
turned him around. It was not in looking back there he would find
himself. He was not back there to be found. Only so much of him
lived as had been able to wing itself ahead—on in the direction she
It did not particularly surprise him that when she at last spoke it
was to voice a shade of that same feeling. "I was thinking," she
began, "of that younger man. Of what he must mean to the man who
gives way to him."
She was feeling her way as she went—groping among the many dim
things that were there. He had always liked to watch her face when
she was thinking her way step by step.
"I think you used a word wrongly a minute ago," she said, with a
smile. "You spoke of being replaced. But that isn't it. A man like
you isn't replaced; he's"—she got it after a minute and came forth
with it triumphantly—"fulfilled!"
Her face was shining as she turned to him after that. "Don't you
see? He's there waiting to take your place because you got him
ready. Why, you made that younger man! Your whole life has been a
getting ready for him. He can do his work be cause you first did
yours. Of course he can go farther than you can! Wouldn't it be a
sorry commentary on you if he couldn't?"
Her voice throbbed warmly upon that last, and during the pause the
light it had brought still played upon her face. "We were talking in
class about immortality," she went on, more slowly. "There's one
form of immortality I like to think about. It's that all those who
from the very first have given anything to the world are living in
the world to-day." There was a rush of tears to her eyes and of
affection to her voice as she finished, very low: "You'll never die.
You've deepened the consciousness of life too much for that."
They sat there as twilight drew near to night, the old man and the
young girl, silent. The laughter of boys and girls and the
good-night calls of the birds were all around them. The fragrance of
life was around them. It was one of those silences to which come
impressions, faiths, longings, not yet born as thoughts.
Something in the quality of that silence brought the rescuing sense
of its having been good to have lived and done one's part—that
sense which, from places of desolation and over ways rough and steep
and dark, can find its way to the meadows of serenity.
More information about Susan Glaspell from Wikipedia
More selections (55) in this category: Short Stories
More selections (163) in the iTunes category: Arts/Literature